Sample 1
Which of the following is the most effective way to provide feedback on a student's first draft in a process-oriented writing class?
In process-oriented writing instruction, the first draft is rough and experimental—students are still discovering ideas. Feedback at this stage should focus on big-picture issues like clarity and organization because correcting every comma and spelling mistake can make the writer feel their ideas don't matter. If a teacher covers a draft in red corrections, students often become discouraged and stop writing altogether. Comments on clarity—'This paragraph confused me, can you explain what you mean?'—push students to think more deeply about their content. Later drafts, at the editing stage, are where you address grammar and mechanics.
Why the other choices are wrong
- A. Circling every error overwhelms emerging writers and shifts focus from content to trivial mistakes.
- B. A numerical grade with no comment gives students no guidance on how to revise.
- D. Rewriting sentences removes the student's voice and doesn't teach them to improve their own writing.